Skip to main content
Guide
6 min read1 February 2024

Replacement Vehicle Options When Your Car Is Being Repaired

An honest explanation of replacement vehicle options for not-at-fault drivers, including rental, credit hire, and what to consider.

Your Options for a Replacement Vehicle

When your car is off the road after an accident, you need to get around. Here are the main options and what to consider with each.

Option 1: Use Your Own Insurance Cover

If you have comprehensive insurance with rental car cover:

  • Contact your insurer to arrange a rental
  • You may need to pay excess upfront
  • The rental may be limited in duration or vehicle class
  • This uses your own policy, not the at-fault driver's

Option 2: Direct Rental (Self-Funded)

You can rent a vehicle yourself and seek reimbursement:

  • You pay for the rental upfront
  • Claim reimbursement from the at-fault party's insurer
  • Keep all receipts and rental agreements
  • Recovery is not guaranteed and may take time

Option 3: Insurer-Approved Replacement

Some at-fault insurers will directly arrange a replacement:

  • The insurer pays the rental company directly
  • Usually limited to the repair period
  • Vehicle class may be basic
  • Generally the simplest option if available

Option 4: Credit Hire Arrangements

Credit hire involves using a vehicle on a "no upfront cost" basis, with the costs recovered from the at-fault party:

How it works:

  • You receive a vehicle without paying upfront
  • The hire company pursues recovery from the at-fault insurer
  • If recovery is successful, you pay nothing
  • If recovery fails or is partial, you may be liable for some costs

Important considerations:

  • Daily rates can be higher than standard rentals
  • You must read and understand the hire agreement
  • Check what happens if liability is disputed
  • Understand any obligations (providing statements, attending court if needed)

What OneCallClaims Does

We work with both rental and credit hire providers. We will:

  • Explain the options available for your situation
  • Be clear about any agreements and what they mean
  • Not pressure you into any arrangement
  • Recommend you read all documents before signing

Questions to Ask About Any Replacement Vehicle

  • Who is responsible for the cost?
  • What happens if the at-fault insurer doesn't pay?
  • What are the daily rates?
  • Is there a limit on how long I can have the vehicle?
  • What are my obligations under the agreement?
  • Can I get a similar vehicle to my own car?
  • Our Commitment to Transparency

    We believe you should understand your options before making a decision. We will:

    • Provide clear, plain-English explanations
    • Never hide costs or obligations in fine print
    • Encourage you to ask questions
    • Support your right to choose the option that suits you

    If you're unsure about any replacement vehicle arrangement, don't sign until you understand it – and feel free to contact us with questions.

    Been in an accident that wasn\'t your fault?

    Check your eligibility for our claim management service.